Zanesville's Home for Cards & Collectibles

Hey there, card collector! Come on in — we've got a shelf with your name on it.

Whether you're hunting for that one rookie card that completes your set, flipping boxes at the kitchen table, or just getting your kid started in the hobby, Zanesville Card Shop is your local spot to find something special.

Find Us in Zanesville Browse What We Carry
Stack of graded sports trading cards in protective cases
1000+ Cards in stock
Local Family-owned shop
Colorful trading card binders and display boxes
About Us

More than a card shop — we're your hobby hub

Zanesville Card Shop, operated by Varsity Collectibles, LLC, has been a part of the Zanesville community for years. We started as a group of friends who loved the thrill of the hunt — that moment when you crack open a pack and find exactly what you've been looking for. That feeling is what we bring to the shop every day.

Curated Selection

Every box, binder, and single card on our shelves is picked with care. We stock what collectors actually want — from budget-friendly options to premium releases.

Community First

We're right here on S. Maysville Ave, and we love seeing familiar faces. Whether you're a veteran collector or buying your first pack, you'll get a friendly welcome.

Fair Prices

No surprises at the register. We price our inventory honestly so you know exactly what you're getting — whether it's a dollar bill box or a graded gem.

What We Carry

Everything your collection needs

From sealed boxes to loose singles, we've got the hobby covered. Here's a look at what you'll find when you walk through our doors.

Sports trading cards featuring baseball, basketball, and football players

Sports Cards

Baseball, basketball, football, hockey — we carry the major brands and everything in between. Current releases and vintage finds.

Colorful Pokémon trading cards arranged on a table

Trading Card Games

Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, and more. Sealed product, singles, sleeves, decks, and accessories.

Vintage and retro sports trading cards in protective slabs

Vintage & Graded

Older issues, vintage boxes, and graded cards in slabs. A rotating selection of pieces with real history behind them.

Card sleeves, binders, top loaders, and display boxes

Accessories & Supplies

Top loaders, magnetic boxes, penny sleeves, binders, and display cases. Everything you need to protect and showcase your collection.

Stop By

Ready to find your next grab?

Our shelves are always changing — new inventory arrives regularly, and there's always something you didn't know you were looking for. Come browse, chat about the hobby, or just say hi.

  • Fresh stock added often
  • Competitive pricing
  • Friendly, knowledgeable staff
  • Great for all skill levels
Interior view of a card shop with shelves of collectible cards and trading card displays

Walk-ins welcome during business hours

Visit Us

Find us in downtown Zanesville

We're easy to find, right off S. Maysville Ave. Pull in, park, and take your time browsing.

Address

1719 S Maysville Ave
Zanesville, OH 43701

Get in Touch

Have a question? We'd love to hear from you

Whether you want to know if we have a specific card in stock, need advice on starting a collection, or just want to say hello — drop us a line.

Quick Contact

Prefer to reach out directly? Here's the fastest way to find us.

(740) 452-0065 thevarsitycollector@gmail.com
1719 S Maysville Ave, Zanesville, OH 43701

Hours

We're typically open most days — but hours can vary, so give us a call ahead if you're making a special trip.

Monday – Friday Call for current hours
Saturday Call for current hours
Sunday Call for current hours

Call (740) 452-0065 to confirm before visiting.

Is this your business?This is my business